The Timberjay logo
Serving Northern St. Louis County, Minnesota

High water rates prompt questions in Tower

30 percent higher for same service than nearby Soudan

Posted 2/16/22

TOWER-SOUDAN— Residents of Tower pay nearly 30-percent more for their water and sewer service than residents of nearby Soudan, even though both communities are served by a joint system that …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

High water rates prompt questions in Tower

30 percent higher for same service than nearby Soudan

Posted

TOWER-SOUDAN— Residents of Tower pay nearly 30-percent more for their water and sewer service than residents of nearby Soudan, even though both communities are served by a joint system that charges each community the same rate for the services it receives.
The difference in the rates charged by the two communities is significant and has been a sore point with Tower residents for years. Yet city officials have been hearing more about the issue since approving a rate increase that adds $20 a quarter to bills that were already substantially higher than their neighbors in Soudan.
The concerns prompted a weeks-long investigation by the Timberjay to better understand why the same service costs so much more in Tower.
Michael Schultz, the city’s new clerk-treasurer, told the city council this week that he’s been researching the issue as well, and has found that the city’s water and sewer billing hasn’t been as reflective of actual costs as it should be and he promised updates will be coming soon. “There’s nothing that the city is trying to hide, but it could be a lot more transparent,” said Schultz.
At the same time, he noted that the city’s water and sewer budget is complex and has proven more difficult to understand than he had expected.
Schultz’s comments reflect the findings of the Timberjay’s own research.
Under the joint powers agreement that created the Tower-Breitung Waste Water Board (TBWWB), which operates the two towns’ municipal water and sewage treatment facility, both communities are charged monthly on a per-gallon basis for the water their residents use and the sewage they generate. Up until this year, the TBWWB also charged the communities for additional costs, such as debt service, operations and maintenance, and building a capital reserve, based on the number of connections in the two towns.
As of mid-2021, Tower had 247 connections, to 245 for Breitung, although the wastewater board increased its quarterly assessments to Tower beginning in October when it increased the number of connections to 272. The number of Breitung connections increased at the same time to 248.
The Timberjay sought an explanation for the increase in the number of connections in Tower, which adds about $1,500 a quarter to Tower’s billing from the TBWWB. City officials suggest that it’s been years since the number was changed and that the increase may reflect a gradual increase in new connections over the past several years.
The TBWWB has no authority over how the two communities allocate the water and sewer expenses to their own residents, and both communities do it differently. While the charges to each community from the TBWWB make up a considerable portion of the total cost charged to customers, both communities have additional costs associated with maintaining their own water and sewer infrastructure and those costs are passed along to customers as well.
Customers in Breitung are also continuing to pay about $7.50 a quarter to retire debt from a loan from the state Public Facilities Authority, or PFA. Tower currently has no water and sewer loans that are assessed to its general customer base.
Despite that, residents in Tower pay considerably more for their water and sewer. After both communities instituted increases in water and sewer fees effective Jan. 1, 2022, residents of Breitung will pay $195 per quarter for water and sewer, an increase of $15 over last year’s residential charges. Residents in Tower saw a $20 increase, leaving residential customers in Tower paying $253.50 per quarter. That’s a difference of $58.50 per quarter, or $234 per year.
Residents of Tower pay more for virtually every part of their quarterly water and sewer bill, and have done so for years. Following the rate increase instituted by both communities this year, the standard quarterly charge for sewer is $69 in Breitung, compared to $100.50 for residents of Tower. The standard quarterly charge for water increased this year to $63 in Breitung, while Tower residents will pay $68 for water.
That’s despite the fact the TBWWB charges both communities the same rate for water and sewer. City officials in Tower provided comment for this story and suggested that the city uses more water and sewer capacity than Breitung, which accounts for some of the difference in utility charges between the two communities. In fact, in 2021, both communities used almost exactly the same amount of water— 13,264,470 gallons in Breitung versus 13,309,090 gallons in Tower.
Tower paid for considerably more sewage discharge, a total of 19,481,100 gallons for Tower versus 14,695,980 gallons in Soudan. The much greater sewage flow in Tower likely reflects the fact that some commercial users, or institutional users such as schools, generate more sewage than the overwhelmingly residential customer base in Soudan. That should not impact residential customers, however, as long as Tower is charging commercial customers, particularly large generators, appropriately.
That doesn’t always happen, it turns out. The city did create another large user of sewage capacity in 2018, when it connected the old and leaky sewage collection infrastructure at the city-owned Hoodoo Point Campground to the municipal system. The campground generates about 700,000 gallons of wastewater annually, which increased the city’s total sewage discharge by about 3.5 percent. But the city doesn’t bill the campground for the sewage it generates, leaving the rest of the city’s ratepayers to cover that expense. Schultz, when asked about the issue, said that’s something that he hopes to bring to the city council’s attention.
In either case, the overall cost difference is relatively minor and could only contribute a small portion to the higher rates in Tower. Indeed, the TBWWB billed the city a total of $21,429 for its sewage discharge in 2021, compared to $17,529 for Soudan, a difference of just $3,900. Even if large generators were charged no more for their sewer service than residential customers, that would add no more than $3.95 to a quarterly residential bill in Tower.
In total, the TBWWB billed the city of Tower $121,448 in 2021, compared to $114,372 for Breitung. Those TBWWB bills include the cost of providing water and sewer as well as the cost of debt service, operations and maintenance, and building a capital reserve for the jointly-run system, which includes drinking water wells, a drinking water filtration plant, a water tower, sewage treatment ponds, and all of the piping needed to collect sewage and distribute drinking water to and from the two communities.
In 2021, Breitung customers were billed (under the water and sewer line items on their quarterly bills) a total of $114,660, essentially matching what the township was billed by the TBWWB.
Both communities do have additional costs, associated with the operation and maintenance of their own water and sewer infrastructure, yet those costs are supposed to be covered by additional line items on the quarterly bills they send to customers. In Breitung, the quarterly bills include extra charges to cover those costs and they’re shown as a $30 charge for “Infrastructure Quarterly,” $16.50 for “Plant Quarterly,” and $16.50 for “Tank Quarterly.”
Those charges generated another $61,740 in fees for the township, just covering the $59,480 in township expenses related to the operation and maintenance of its infrastructure. The township’s handling of its water and sewer billing appears to be straightforward and quite accurately reflects its actual costs. The “water” and “sewer” line items on their bills were in line with the actual charges from the TBWWB and the additional fees just covered the reported township expenses.
Customers in Tower paid considerably more. For just the water and sewer line items, customers in Tower were billed in excess of $147,000 last year, more than $25,000 above and beyond what the TBWWB actually charged the city for water and sewer. Yet the city also charged its customers $16.50 per quarter for a line item titled “capital reserve.” Those dollars, however, do not go to a city reserve account. Instead, those funds go to the TBWWB and were already included in the $121,448 that the TBWWB billed the city in 2021. The same is true for the $28.60 charge per quarter for what has been incorrectly listed on the city’s quarterly bills as “filtration debt.” That charge had been used to pay down a PFA loan for the construction of the TBWWB’s water filtration plant back in 2000. That loan was fully retired in August 2019, but the charge has remained on water and sewer bills in Tower for the past two and a half years. According to TBWWB operations manager Matt Tuchel, the TBWWB opted to continue to collect the $28.60 charge to help fund the costs of operating the filtration plant and build a reserve fund to cover anticipated future debt for construction of a new drinking water treatment plant. The new plant is needed to address violations stemming from surface water contamination of the TBWWB’s drinking water wells.
Combined, the city collects approximately $191,000 from its customers for TBWWB services that cost the city just over $121,000.
On top of that, the city collects a $2.50 state fee that doesn’t appear on customers’ bills in Breitung as well as a $37.40 charge that is supposed to cover operations and maintenance of the city’s own water and sewer infrastructure. That fee generated about $37,000 last year.
According to city officials, Tower collected a total of $248,000 in water and sewer charges in 2021, or approximately $127,000 more than it was charged by the TBWWB. At the same time, city data provided to the Timberjay shows that the city barely covered its expenses of $245,000 to provide water and sewer to its customers.
Breitung township charged Soudan residents a total of approximately $176,000. That compares to costs totaling $174,000.
Why the difference?
From an examination of city and township budgets, it appears that the city spent somewhat more for employee wages and benefits attributed to its water and sewer accounts than Breitung did this past year. In 2021, the city spent $43,870 on wages and benefits, compared to $36,540 for the township. City wages may have been higher than usual in 2021, however, since public works staff spent more time addressing problems with inflow and infiltration, which is responsible for some of the city’s higher demand for sewage capacity. In 2020, for example, city wages and benefits attributable to water and sewer totaled just $30,562. Much of the increase in wages and benefits in 2021 was the result of the city assessing substantially more of its health insurance costs to its water and sewer accounts than the year before, although that may have been done in error. If so, the wage and related costs for both the city and the township would be nearly identical.
The city also allocated $15,000 to conduct camera inspections of its sewer lines to try to pinpoint areas of inflow and infiltration, which pushed repair and maintenance costs in 2021 to $26,375, or nearly double the $13,253 the city spent in 2020. In addition, the city spent $18,213 on engineering services, most likely for work on the proposed new water main. It’s not clear, however, whether that project will move ahead any time soon, due to lack of funding.
Breitung did report higher costs than Tower in its “supplies” expense line, reporting total costs of $20,893, well above the $4,643 spent by the city. Tower also paid slightly less for insuring its infrastructure, a total of $690 compared to $955 in Breitung.
Because the city and the township track and report their expenses differently, direct comparisons are not straightforward.
Schultz did suggest this week that the city could form a committee to delve more deeply into the issue and try to reconfigure the city’s water and sewer budget and the line items on the bills sent to customers. Schultz noted that the TBWWB has significantly changed the way it now bills both the city and the township, which could make it an opportune time to reconfigure the city’s budgets and billing. The council took no action on his suggestion.