The Timberjay logo
Serving Northern St. Louis County, Minnesota

School district awarded variance for North School

Posted 1/20/11

Plans for the New North School in Field Township appear back on track, following the St. Louis County Board of Adjustment’s decision to grant a critical variance for the project.

The 3-1 vote in …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

School district awarded variance for North School

Posted

Plans for the New North School in Field Township appear back on track, following the St. Louis County Board of Adjustment’s decision to grant a critical variance for the project.

The 3-1 vote in favor of the variance was the final zoning hurdle for the proposed $30 million project, but the effort still faces the possibility of a legal challenge by township officials who have opposed the plan from the beginning.

School officials made the case for the variance before a shorthanded board of adjustment that just met the quorum requirement of the normally seven-member board. Speaking for the district, school board member Gary Rantala said the selected site was the result of a lengthy planning effort that used a number of criteria to select the best location.

Both Rantala and consulting engineer Chris Shaw noted repeatedly that the stormwater plan developed for the site was designed to reduce runoff, despite the fact that the school project would increase impervious surfaces on the property.

At issue was the amount of lot coverage allowed under the county ordinance. The property in question is zoned Forest and Agricultural Management-2, which limits lot coverage to just two percent. The school project, which involves 14.1 percent lot coverage, would exceed the standard by just over seven times.

But county planning staff had recommended approval of the variance, contending that the stormwater plan would reduce the water quality impacts from the higher lot coverage and that it would not have an effect on government services in the area. The staff report also stated that while the project would change the character of the neighborhood, the parcel would still retain large open and forested areas, which would tend to mitigate its impact.

Both county staff and school officials noted that the plan had already been through considerable review, including an environmental assessment worksheet and permitting by the county planning commission and the state Pollution Control Agency and Department of Education.

While county staff tried to keep the discussion on the issue of the variance, several supporters of the proposal spoke in favor of the variance, citing their beliefs that the new school will provide a “modern” education for students. School board member Bob Larson said the school district was going to build the new school regardless of the decision on the variance, and any change from the proposed plan would take money away from students. School board member Zelda Bruns noted that a considerable amount of public money had already been invested in the proposed location.

But the plan did face continued opposition, mostly from nearby residents and the Field Town Board itself, which voted to oppose the variance request. Town Board Chair Keith Aho took issue with some of the findings of the staff report and noted that many alternative sites that would not have required variances were overlooked in the school district’s search process. “We believe the hardship was created by the applicant, certainly not by the lot,” he said. “This site was selected without consideration of the zoning requirements.” He noted that other locations in Field Township would not have required a variance. School officials did acknowledge under questioning at one point, that one of the sites they had identified would not have required a variance.

That point prompted a question from board of adjustment member David Pollock, who asked whether Johnson Controls, the district’s consultant, had ever raised the issue of zoning in the school district’s site selection search. Superintendent Charles Rick declined to answer directly, but acknowledged that the discussions had focused on other issues. “I have a problem with that,” said Pollock.

Kathleen McQuillan, a Cook area resident, questioned the veracity of information that the school district had provided the public and complained that board members had ignored public concerns throughout the process. “They’re operating seven schools in the black, when voters were told they were facing a $4.1 million deficit.”

Pollock asked about ongoing investigations into possible misinformation, noting discrepancies uncovered in a recently-released spreadsheet developed by Johnson Controls. He asked Rick whether the district was looking into those issues. “Our legal counsel is looking into it,” he said, without elaborating.

Pollock questioned whether the issue would even be before the board if information had not been “massaged.”

Still, such concerns didn’t carry the day. Shortly after closing the public hearing, board of adjustment member William “Tom” Coombe made the motion to approve the variance. Members Steve Filipovich and Diana Werschay voted in favor, while Pollock voted no.

The absence of two members likely made the difference. The board had denied a variance on a 3-3 vote last summer for the school district’s new school project in New Independence Township. But two of the members who had voted against that request were absent from Tuesday’s meeting. Marilyn Mueller’s tenure on the board expired in December, while attorney Kelly Klun did not attend Tuesday’s meeting.

School officials relieved

School officials were clearly pleased in the wake of the decision. The district has faced a bumpy road, experiencing setbacks at various points in the county planning process. Superintendent Rick said the district was better able to make its case this time around than it had earlier on the south project. “We learned a lot from that experience and prepared the best we could, “ said Rick.

The next steps will be to call for bids on the different project components, including constructing a road to the site. Rick expects the board to discuss that process in more detail when it meets this Monday.

Ideally, the district will still be able to take advantage of a highly competitive environment for contractors, Rick added. “Time will tell but we’re hoping to attract some good bids” with contractors still scrambling for work in the slowly recovering economy.

Work on the north school project isn’t expected to begin until spring. Rick said the new school should be open for students by the fall of 2012. That’s a year later than anticipated and means the district will have to make other arrangements for students at Cook and Orr for the 2011-12 school year.

Board members are scheduled to meet at 4 p.m. on Thursday, Jan. 27 in a study session to discuss options for the students. The district could choose to keep both the Orr and Cook schools open for another year or opt to close one of the schools and combine students at either Orr or Cook. Business manager Kim Johnson is preparing a cost analysis of the different options available to the board.

Legal challenge ahead?

Opponents weren’t ruling out a legal challenge in the wake of Tuesday’s vote. “I’ll have to visit with our attorneys and the town board and also the joint powers board,” said Keith Aho following the decision. “I think we have the precedent to overturn the decision, but it’s more a question of whether we have the financial resources at this point.”

variance, St. Louis County, ISD 2142