I attended and spoke at the open planning and zoning commission meeting regarding the proposed project at Silver Rapids Lodge earlier this month. I was surprised and disappointed that, despite the overwhelming support of the approximately 90 people in attendance and the serious issues raised at the meeting as well as subsequent concerns raised in writing by numerous parties, the comment period regarding this project is now closed.
I would like to suggest that, given the following points, it seems more than appropriate and fair to reopen the comment period before the commission makes its final decision regarding this project.  This project promises to have an extremely significant impact on all those living in the WICOLA chain as well as others in the Ely area.
Reopening the comment period is indicated in this situation and would allow for:
1. New Information to be gathered and shared with the public in compliance with procedural fairness. At the earlier meeting, both speakers and the county staff raised substantial concerns that were not sufficiently addressed by the developers. Questions regarding water quality, traffic and pedestrian safety concerns, density and placement of housing units and boat slips, and legal questions regarding the current application all need to be adequately responded to by the proposers.
2. Respect for the high public interest evidenced by attendance at the planning and zoning meeting and the fact that announcement of the meeting was insufficiently advertised to those most immediately impacted by the project also support the reopening of a comment period. Key stakeholders, such as local businesses, environmental groups, and affected residents all deserve more time to prepare their comments.
The complexity of this ambitious and potentially contentious project suggests that reopening the comment period can ensure that all viewpoints are heard and definitely considered. Whatever the final decision, taking time to listen to all those concerned will lead to a more informed and equitable resolution.
Sharon Friedler
Ely