The Timberjay logo
Serving Northern St. Louis County, Minnesota

ISD 2142 flouts state law in closure of Orr School

Posted 2/12/11

The St. Louis County School Board failed to conduct a state-required public hearing before voting to close the Orr School and may have to scrap a Jan. 31 motion that would send Orr students to the …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

ISD 2142 flouts state law in closure of Orr School

Posted

The St. Louis County School Board failed to conduct a state-required public hearing before voting to close the Orr School and may have to scrap a Jan. 31 motion that would send Orr students to the Cook School next fall.

Although school officials claim it was an oversight, some speculate the district deliberately avoided the hearing because it lacked sufficient time to complete the process and close the school next fall.

School board Chairwoman Zelda Bruns, who represents the Orr attendance area and opposed the school’s closure, plans to ask the board to rescind its Jan. 31 motion and request a public hearing on the school’s closure. She has requested the issue be added to the board’s agenda for its meeting on Monday at 5 p.m. at the Virginia administrative office.

State statute

At issue is Minnesota Statute 123B.51, Subdivision 5 which states that a district may close a school following a public hearing where people, either for or against the action, can testify.

The district must publish a public notice for two weeks in the district’s official newspaper prior to the hearing, stating the time and place of the hearing and including the location and description of the school proposed for closure. It must also state its reasons for closing the school.

Superintendent Charles Rick said that a hearing will be conducted but said the district was not in violation of state law by acting on the Jan. 31 motion in advance of the hearing.

He suggested that because students are being transferred from the Orr facility to Cook, the board did not vote technically to close the school. But legal precedent says otherwise. The Minnesota Court of Appeals rejected a similar argument by the Mountain Iron-Buhl School District in 1988 when it claimed it had not closed a school because it kept portions of the building open and had 20 students taking part in a course there.

In its ruling, the court noted that no full curriculum and few activities were offered at the site. “The doors of the school may be open, but for all practical purposes, the building does not exist as a school,” the court stated in its ruling.

District 2142 has no plan to use the Orr School next fall and is scheduled to cut heat and other utility services to the building.

The argument that the district hasn’t officially closed the school is further undercut by its claims that closing the Orr School will net the district nearly $400,000 in savings.

In addition, the district has already conducted public hearings at both Cotton and AlBrook in anticipation of plans to close schools there and transfer students to a new school being built in Independence Township. A recording officer was present at both hearings to document the public’s testimony. Bruns said she’ll ask for the same treatment for the Orr School and said the hearing should be conducted in Orr.

Ironically, it may be because of those hearings that ISD 2142 sidestepped the process in Orr. Rick said the district just received a report from the hearing judge on testimony taken at those hearings. The district will review the report before moving forward on a motion to close the AlBrook and Cotton schools. According to Rick, the hearing judge recommends action, but the board can take whatever action it deems appropriate.

School officials said they needed a decision on the Orr School by the end of January to move forward on staffing and scheduling for the next year. The board’s urgency was underscored by the fact that it scheduled a special meeting on Jan. 31 specifically to decide the fate of the Orr School.

If they were required to wait until the completion of the hearing process, school officials might not have been able to proceed until late April or May.

Rick told the Timberjay earlier in the week that the district would do whatever it must to fulfill the law.

Controversial

decision

The board’s 4-3 vote to close the Orr School at the end of the current school year split the board and drew criticism from audience members from Orr and Nett Lake who attended the special meeting.

Those in favor of the motion said combining students at Cook would not only save the district money but also produce educational benefits for students. Superintendent Rick said merging students at one site would eliminate the need for some interactive television courses and provide more “face-to-face” teaching time for students.

Music and other educational programs would benefit by providing more electives, he added.

But opponents questioned some of the savings and feared the decision would increase tensions over an already contentious restructuring plan and affect future support and enrollment for the school.

School board members Bruns and Chet Larson also noted that the board had promised not to move students until the new school was constructed and that going back on their word would further erode trust in the district.

Several Nett Lake parents said it would help smooth the transition if Orr were allowed to remain open another year. Teacher Nancy Parvi, who has taught in Orr since 1980, concurred.

“I worry that all the good work that we have done and spent so many years to build is fragile if we come together too soon,” said Parvi, who spoke about how Orr and Nett Lake had overcome early friction to forge a strong relationship. “God forbid that we lose the Nett Lake community. Cook is going to be amazed at what we bring to the table and they are going to be less amazed if we don’t have our friends from Nett Lake.”

Meanwhile, it appears both sides may get another opportunity to plead their cases, opening the possibility that the Orr School could remain open another year. The board was divided 4-3 on the last vote; if one member of the majority reverses his or her decision, the Orr School would not be closed next fall.