ELY- Frontier customers who rely on traditional copper telephone lines may eventually be asked to switch to a different type of service, but a Verizon representative told an Ely audience recently that no one will lose service this year under the company’s proposal.
Customers who lack a workable alternative would keep their copper service, said Paul Vasington, Verizon’s senior director of government affairs. The proposed change has not yet been approved by the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission.
Vasington spoke at The Hub during the first in a series of public forums arranged by the PUC’s Consumer Affairs Office. Representatives from that office and the Minnesota Attorney General’s Office also attended, explaining how residents can submit comments on the proposal.
Vasington was there on behalf of Frontier Communications, which Verizon purchased in January. Frontier has provided copper-line telephone service to customers in the Ely area and elsewhere in Minnesota.
About 11,000 Frontier copper customers statewide received an initial notice of the proposed change, Vasington said. From that group, the company will identify customers who would be affected and send them additional notices.
Two alternatives
Under the proposal, Frontier would look at whether customers have access to either of two alternatives: a landline connection using fiber-optic service or a fixed wireless home-phone service called Voice Connect.
The wireless option uses a device installed in the home to connect calls over the wireless network. Customers could continue using their existing home phones and, if they choose, their existing interior phone wiring, Vasington said. He said customers could also keep their current phone numbers.
For customers without fiber service, Vasington said a Frontier technician would visit the home to test whether the wireless option works before making a change.
“If there is a location where neither of those options is available, so you don’t have fiber available at your house, and wireless service is not sufficient at your house, for those locations, we will not discontinue the copper network,” he said.
Several people questioned how dependable wireless service would be in an area where cell coverage can vary considerably from one location to another. Bob Patrick, who spent a decade working in telecommunications engineering, wanted to know how the company would determine whether an alternative would work at a customer’s home.
“How’s that to be determined by who or what, because there are many pockets along the Echo Trail. There are many pockets in the area of Portage Township,” Patrick said.
Vasington said the company would not rely solely on a coverage map. A Frontier technician would test the signal and make a test call at the home before service was changed, he said.
Costs and reliability
Vasington said there would be no charge for equipment or installation as part of the proposed transition.
The Voice Connect service would have two pricing options, he said: a $15 monthly plan under which customers pay separately for outgoing calls, and a $30 monthly plan that includes unlimited calling nationwide and to Canada, Puerto Rico, and U.S. territories, along with additional calling features.
One attendee wanted to know whether the advertised price would cover her entire phone bill or be added to her existing charges.
Vasington initially described the price as the bill for phone service. Further questions brought out a distinction: the $15 and $30 figures are the prices for the service itself, not the total customers would see on their bills. He said taxes and other charges, including a federal Universal Service Fund charge, would be added. Customers using Voice Connect would not pay the separate subscriber line charge that appears on current copper-line bills, he said.
Fiber home-phone service would cost $30 a month, but it requires fiber broadband service, which would be priced separately, he said.
Residents also asked about emergency calls and power outages. Vasington said the wireless device would be installed at a fixed location in the home and would provide location information for 911 calls. It operates on household power and has a battery backup that he said would allow regular calls, not just emergency calls, during an outage.
Business questions
For Blayne and Charlene Hall of Williams and Hall Outfitters, the discussion raised questions about how a change would affect a business with multiple phone lines.
“What if you have more than one line? Is the pricing the same?” Charlene Hall asked.
Vasington said the price would be per phone number, so a business with multiple lines and different numbers would pay a separate charge for each.
The Halls also asked about the ability to roll an incoming call over to another line when the first is busy, a feature that helps a business avoid missing calls. Vasington said he did not know the answer and would look into it.
Blayne Hall said the meeting raised questions for both businesses and homeowners, whose communications needs can be very different.
Internet service
One customer asked what would happen to internet service provided over Frontier’s copper lines, commonly known as DSL.
“So, does this transition affect the internet service that’s being provided?” the customer asked.
Vasington said the current proposal concerns telephone service and does not address DSL. He said the company also expects to phase out DSL over time, but does not yet have a comparable overall plan or schedule for that transition.
Next steps
The PUC has not yet decided whether to approve the customer transition plan. Vasington said the company expects to evaluate individual addresses and send additional notices after the state process is complete, likely sometime in 2027, although the timing depends on the commission.
PUC Consumer Affairs Supervisor Anne Thom encouraged residents to submit comments on the proposal to the commission. Comments should include docket number 26-266 and can be emailed to consumer.puc@state.mn.us or submitted through the Consumer Affairs page at mn.gov/puc. The office can also be reached at 651-296-0406 or 800-657-3782.
Assistant Attorney General Wendy Raymond said residents can also contact the Attorney General’s Office with complaints at 800-657-3787.