I was struck by the geographical divide in District 3A, based on the results of the Nov. 3 election, so we’ve mapped the vote by color to highlight just how much the partisan affiliations change in District 3A as you move east-to-west.
This trend highlights an issue that I believe is important for DFL-affiliated candidates in the region. For years, there has been significant hand wringing over whether a candidate who is openly opposed to copper-nickel mining could actually win in 3A. Based on the current makeup of District 3A, it is likely to be a challenge for a DFL candidate, regardless of their position on mining. As we saw four years ago, GOP challenger Roger Skraba defeated Rob Ecklund, a sitting DFL incumbent who had repeatedly staked out firm support for the possibility of copper-nickel mining, even the Twin Metals project, the most controversial of the proposals out there.
There was plenty of said hand wringing this past August, when Gov. Tim Walz, put a temporary freeze on any state action to advance any mining proposals within the upper Rainy River watershed. In terms of actual impact, it was a snoozer, but it certainly energized the activists on both sides of the issue. Its salience as a real campaign issue, that affected how people voted, remains less clear. In the end, I don’t see any evidence that it changed enough votes to matter.
When you look at the vote totals, it was pretty clear that there was little ticket splitting. Both Republican and DFL candidates right down each ticket received very similar vote totals, with a few minor exceptions.
If copper-nickel mining was an issue with voters, there would have been a greater disparity. Yet Trina Swanson, who had made her opposition to the Twin Metals project a major point in her run against incumbent Pete Stauber, proved to be the second-highest DFL vote-getter in 3A, narrowly losing to Stauber, with 11,266 votes to Stauber’s 11,490.
Looked at by county, Swanson crushed Stauber in St. Louis, Lake, and Cook counties, the only places that could conceivably be impacted by a Twin Metals project.
The only DFLer to top her was incumbent Sen. Grant Hauschild, who garnered 11,771 votes, or about 500 more than Swanson across the district. While Hauschild has been strongly supportive of advancing the Twin Metals and other copper-nickel projects, I highly doubt that support accounted for this difference. Incumbents almost always have an advantage in a local contest and that’s especially so for Hauschild, who has distinguished himself as a hard worker and thoughtful strategist who made things happen for the region. And, as in his first campaign, he simply out hustled his opponent.
That wasn’t the case in the District 3A race. DFL challenger Aaron Kania put in a very credible effort, but his 827-vote loss to Skraba was not surprising. Again, incumbents have a natural advantage, and Skraba has been smart to tag team with Hauschild to a fair degree. Skraba, who describes himself as an “Oberstar Democrat,” isn’t an ideologue and as a former mayor he understands the importance of state funding for our communities and has supported that funding while many in his current party don’t. Had he proven to be a doctrinaire Republican in the House over the past two terms, he would likely have been ousted on Nov. 3.
Kania’s position on copper-nickel, was more in line with Hauschild’s than Swanson’s, yet Swanson pulled slightly more votes in the district than Kania. By that fact, one might assume that opposition to copper-nickel mining is a net political positive in the district.
The above map is the best evidence for that. When you look at the communities that would be impacted by a Twin Metals mine, for example, they largely voted blue, in many cases by wide margins. Ely voted narrowly for Kania, even though Skraba is a former mayor there. Fall Lake Township and virtually all the rest of Lake County (the Silver Bay area being an exception) went for Kania even more strongly. Even Hoyt Lakes, the community that would arguably be most affected by proposed copper-nickel mining went narrowly for Kania.
Babbitt voted strongly Republican, but that was true regardless of the DFL candidates’ individual position on Twin Metals. Babbitt has become a GOP stronghold, as evidenced by the past several elections.
What has changed more than anything is the geography of District 3A, which now extends much further west into areas where Republican dominance has become entrenched, and not because of the mining issue. The communities that make 3A challenging for DFL candidates are more than 100 miles away from any proposed mines and would be little affected regardless of what happens on that front.
Take the boundaries of the old House District 6A, which had encompassed the Arrowhead up until the 2012 election (but did not include Koochiching and parts of Itasca counties), and Kania would have won the House seat in a cake walk. And that is the region that would be affected by copper-nickel mining. In other words, in most of the places where copper-nickel mining is a campaign issue in District 3A, DFLers win.
Those places that are largely unaffected by that debate, Republicans dominate. You can’t take those indisputable facts and conclude that opposition to copper-nickel mining upstream of the Boundary Waters is a political killer for DFLers. That might have been the case at one time. But when the most ardent opponent of the Twin Metals mine is the second highest DFL vote-getter in District 3A, you know the political winds have shifted.